Claim numbers for our carriers. Ron Smith Insurance, LTD. 1 (800) 548-5189 Erie 1(800) 362-6541 Erie (afterhours) 1(800)367-3743 Progressive 1 (800) 925-2886 Foremost 1 (800) 527-3905 Auto-Owners 1 (800) 346-0346 Motorists Mutual 1(800) 876-8766